Biblioteca da Assembleia da Republica

Biblioteca da Assembleia da República

Listas Bibliográficas - 0

|

Recursos Eletrónicos

|

Redefinir pesquisa

Voltar à lista

A pesquisar na Biblioteca da Assembleia da República

Dual identity? : A methodological critique of the Linz-Moreno question as a statistical proxy of national identity
Identidad dual? : Una crítica metodológica a la pergunta Linz-Moreno como indicador estadístico de la identidad nacional / Arturo De Nieves, Carlos Diz

Nieves, Arturo de, 1983-; Diz, Carlos, co-autor

Revista española de ciencia política . ISSN1575-6548 . Madrid : Siglo XXI de Espana, No 49 (Mar. 2019) , p. 13-41

This article develops a methodological critique of a widespread measurement of national identity through surveys, the so-called “Linz-Moreno question’ (LMQ) and of its epistemological foundation, the theory of "dual identity”. We chose Spain as a case study for our research because of its internal variability in terms of identity feelings between its regions and the availability of quality data. We have divided the seventeen Spanish Autonomous Communities (ACs) into four groups, in accordance to their identity structure. We present two big groups of ACs, one including the ACs with primacy of nationwide nationalistic feelings, and the other one containing those ACs with significant presence of sub-state nationalisms.Then, we divide each of these categories into two, attending to the strength of their identity feelings. Using qualitative methodologies, we found differences in the reproduction process of nationalism for each group of ACs. what strengthens the validity of our classification. Finally, we tested our main hypothesis with a multinornial logistic regression that provides empirical evidence showing that the LMQ is not a good indicator of national identity for wealdy nationalized ACs. We conclude that the dual identity theory hides relevant differences related to the hierarchy and nature of collective identities in modern societies. Consequently, we should problematize merely descriptive analyses of collective identities and begin to treat national identity as an ideological expression of nationalism. The critique of the LMQ presented in this article wants to contribute to a better measurement of identities in modern societies. [Da introdução]

Espanha; nacionalismo; identidade nacional

Ver formato UNIMARC

Exportar registo em ISO2709

Exportar registo em MarcXchange

Informações e esclarecimentos
contactar AR

Ligação para sítio SirsiDynix

© 2008 SirsiDynix Todos os direitos reservados.

Biblioteca da Assembleia da Republica